The transfer of Alphonse Omija from Gor Mahia to Tunisia's Etoile Sportive Du Sahel has sparked one of the most heated debates in Kenyan football this year. What should have been a celebration of a young Kenyan talent securing a move abroad has instead become a battleground of accusations, defensive state statements ,and questions about transparency in football transfers
Table of contents [Show]
In September 2025, 22-year-old Kenyan centre-back Alphonse Omija completed his move from Gor Mahia to Tunisian club Etoile Sportive Du Sahel. While Transfermarkt valued the transfer at €200,000, exclusive information reveals that Gor Mahia will actually receive USD 50,000 (approximately KSH 6.46 million) from the deal.
The transfer came on the back of Omija's impressive performances during the TotalEnergies African Nations Championship (CHAN), where his displays on the continental stage caught the attention of scouts and clubs across Africa. Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy endorsed the move, describing it as "the right thing" for the player's development.
However, beneath the surface of what appeared to be a straightforward transfer lies a controversy that has divided Gor Mahia's fanbase and put the club's leadership under intense scrutiny. The primary target of fan criticism has been Vice President Sally Bolo, with supporters raising serious questions about transparency and potential conflicts of interest in the transfer process.
Gor Mahia fans have been particularly vocal about their concerns, with many questioning whether the deal was handled in the club's best interests. The fact that a player of Omija's caliber - fresh off strong CHAN performances that likely increased his market value - was sold for what some perceive as below-market rates has only fueled the fire.
Faced with mounting criticism and what she describes as fans "clamoring for my neck," Sally Bolo issued a detailed statement defending her role in the transfer. Her response provides insight into both the official process and the nature of the accusations against her:
"I have been following, with amazement, the debate over Kenyan international defender Alphonse Omija's transfer from Gor Mahia to Etoil du Sahel of Tunisia. I'm getting plenty of flak, wrongfully, for weakening a club a profess to love."
According to Bolo's account, the transfer followed proper procedures:
Etoile du Sahel approached Gor Mahia with an offer for the player.The Executive Committee deliberated and sanctioned the transfer.
Professional Representation: FIFA-licensed agents from Salient Sports Management, who have represented Omija for four years, negotiated the deal
Regulatory Compliance: The entire process followed FIFA rules and regulations
Bolo emphatically denied personally initiating or orchestrating the transfer, stating:
"I did not initiate the transfer of the player as alluded to by those clamoring for my neck, neither did I sell the player."
The Financial Reality
The financial details of the transfer add another layer to the controversy. With Gor Mahia set to receive USD 50,000 from a player valued at €200,000 on Transfermarkt, questions arise about:
The significant difference between reported market value and actual compensation received
Whether this represents the full fee or just Gor Mahia's percentage remians unknown
For a club that faces regular financial challenges, USD 50,000 represents meaningful revenue, but fans may question whether this adequately reflects the loss of a promising young defender who had been performing at international level.
This controversy extends beyond a single transfer, touching on deeper issues within Kenyan football:
Transparency in Football Governance
The intensity of fan scrutiny reflects broader concerns about transparency in how football clubs conduct business. When supporters question whether their club received fair value for a prized asset, it speaks to trust issues between leadership and fanbase.
Player Development vs. Financial Reality
Omija's move represents the classic dilemma facing Kenyan clubs: balancing the need to develop and retain talent against the financial pressures that make selling players attractive. The timing of the transfer, following strong international performances, suggests it could have been a lucrative opportunity that perhaps wasn't maximized.
Leadership Accountability
The specific targeting of Sally Bolo by fans indicates there may be additional context or relationships that have made supporters particularly suspicious of her role. The defensive nature of her statement suggests the accusations have been specific and persistent.
Despite the controversy surrounding his departure, Omija has maintained loyalty to his former club, stating
" For the past one year, playing for Gor has been a true honor. Very incredible,full of emotions. I will miss every moment, the battles, and the smiles we shared" as he completed his move.
Omija expressed regret that he couldn't say a proper goodbye to the fans, but assured them that his "love for you is endless."
His success at ES Sahel has already led to the Tunisian club showing interest in other Kenyan players, potentially opening doors for more talent from Kenya.
For Gor Mahia, this saga serves as a reminder of the delicate balance required in modern football governance. While the club may have followed proper procedures, the controversy highlights the importance of not just doing things right, but also ensuring the fanbase understands and supports major decisions.
The Alphonse Omija transfer controversy reveals the complex dynamics at play in modern football transfers. While the official process may have been followed correctly, the gap between fan expectations and the actual financial outcome has created a crisis of confidence that extends beyond this single deal.
Whether Sally Bolo's defense will satisfy critics remains to be seen, but the intensity of the debate demonstrates the passion and investment that Gor Mahia fans have in their club's future. In an era where transparency is increasingly demanded by supporters, this case study serves as a reminder that even legitimate business decisions can become controversial when stakeholders feel left in the dark.
As Omija settles into life in Tunisia and Gor Mahia moves forward with their remaining squad, the lessons from this transfer saga will likely influence how the club handles future player movements. The challenge will be balancing financial necessity with fan expectations while maintaining the transparency that modern football governance demands.
The football world will be watching to see whether this controversy leads to changes in how Kenyan clubs handle high-profile transfers, and whether the relationship between Gor Mahia's leadership and its passionate fanbase can be repaired.
Kenya defeats Burundi 1-0 in FIFA World Cup Qualifiers as Ryan Ogam scores 72nd-minute winner. Harambee Stars move to 3rd in Group F with 12 points. Read how the Harambee Stars secured the win with full stats!
Bandari FC defeats AFC Leopards 4-3 on penalties after a 0-0 draw in the ODM @20 semi-final in Mombasa. Ex-Leopards keeper Levis Opiyo becomes the hero. Full match report.
In-depth AFC Leopards vs Bandari FC match preview with head-to-head stats, tactical analysis, score predictions, and betting tips for the Kenyan Premier League clash.
